The Still & The VineSchool of Wine & Spirits
Kilchoman Machir Bay
Scotch WhiskyIssue 22

Kilchoman Machir Bay

Kilchoman Distillery Co. (Independent) · Kilchoman Distillery, Rockside Farm, Islay

$5592 (46% ABV) proofNAS (vatting of bourbon and sherry cask matured whisky)Rockside Farm, Islay — where Anthony Wills built the first new distillery built on Islay since 1908, and one of only a handful of Scottish distilleries still malting barley on-site over traditional peat-fired kilns.
Kilchoman is what happens when someone decides to do everything the hard way — and gets it spectacularly right. Anthony Wills didn't just build a new distillery on Islay; he built one that grows its own barley, malts it over its own peat-fired kiln, and distills in tiny copper pot stills.

Kit Aromas

Tasting Notes

Nose

Peat smoke and sea spray, lemon zest, heather honey, vanilla fudge, with a floral sweetness rising through the smoke

Palate

Maritime peat balanced by orchard fruit, salted caramel, smoked honey, black pepper, and a rich creaminess from the sherry cask influence

Finish

Medium-long with lingering campfire smoke, sea salt, and a clean citrus brightness

Specifications
Distillation
Double distilled in copper pot stills
Maturation
Combination of first-fill bourbon barrels and Oloroso sherry casks
Chill-Filtered
Non-chill filtered, natural color
Serve & Pair

Cocktail Suggestion

Cocktail — The Peat & Honey Highball: 2 oz Kilchoman Machir Bay · 0.5 oz honey syrup (1:1) · 4 oz chilled soda water · Lemon twist. Build over ice in a tall glass, stir gently twice.

Food Pairing

Pair with: Smoked salmon on dark rye bread with a squeeze of lemon — the smoke in both amplifies the maritime character.

Train These Aromas
Comments

Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

0 / 4,000

First-time comments are reviewed before appearing. Be kind, be specific, no spam.

More from Kilchoman Distillery, Rockside Farm, Islay
Ron Zacapa Edición Negra
Rum

Ron Zacapa Edición Negra

Ron Zacapa

Edición Negra takes Zacapa's high-altitude solera system and pushes it toward heavier charred casks, producing a darker, more brooding rum than its siblings. The result is a spirit that trades some of the Centenario 23's honeyed charm for genuine complexity and a savory edge. Whether you sip it neat or pair it with a robust dessert, this is rum built for contemplation.

86 proof
Michter's 10 Year Old Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Bourbon

Michter's 10 Year Old Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Michter's

Michter's 10 Year exemplifies the discipline of selecting barrels that can handle a full decade without tipping into over-oaked bitterness. This is bourbon that rewards slow sipping — each minute in the glass unlocks new layers. A benchmark for what extended aging should accomplish in Kentucky whiskey.

94.4 proof
Don Pilar Añejo Tequila
Tequila

Don Pilar Añejo Tequila

Don Pilar

Don Pilar's Añejo delivers genuine agave character that has been shaped, not masked, by eighteen months in oak. This is añejo the way it should be done — the wood serves the spirit, not the other way around. At its price point, it competes well above its weight class, offering depth and balance that many pricier añejos struggle to achieve.

80 proof
Jensen's Old Tom London Gin
Gin

Jensen's Old Tom London Gin

Jensen's

Christian Jensen spent years researching nineteenth-century recipes to reconstruct an authentic Old Tom profile. The result is not a novelty — it is a genuine revival, offering a window into what gin tasted like before London Dry became the dominant style. Essential for anyone building a historically informed Martinez or Tom Collins.

86 proof
More Scotch Whisky Reviews
Glengoyne 18 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Scotch Whisky

Glengoyne 18 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Glengoyne

Glengoyne prides itself on the slowest distillation in Scotland, and this 18-year expression makes the case for why that matters. The patience at every stage — unhurried distillation, careful sherry cask selection, nearly two decades of maturation — produces a whisky of uncommon depth and balance. A masterclass in time well spent.

86 proof
Arran 14 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Scotch Whisky

Arran 14 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Arran

Arran 14 is island whisky without the smoke, a distillery that trusts its spirit to carry the weight. Non-chill filtered and natural color, it's a transparent window into careful cask management and clean, fruity distillation. One of Scotland's better-kept secrets at this price point.

92 proof
Benromach 15 Year Old
Scotch Whisky

Benromach 15 Year Old

Benromach

Benromach's 15 Year is a masterclass in internal tension: sherry richness versus subtle peat, sweetness versus earthiness. It never leans too far in either direction. This is Speyside with a backbone, a malt that rewards attention without demanding it.

86 proof
Inchgower 14 Year Old Flora & Fauna
Scotch Whisky

Inchgower 14 Year Old Flora & Fauna

Inchgower

Inchgower is one of Speyside's most underappreciated distilleries, and this Flora & Fauna bottling shows why it deserves wider recognition. The coastal influence sets it apart from fruitier Speyside neighbors — there's a savory tension here that makes it more versatile than its modest reputation suggests. An excellent introduction to the distillery's character.

86 proof